Have I Become A Wine Snob??

On My MindI was having a casual dinner with some friends the other night at a local restaurant to catch up on our respective summers.  We ordered an array of salads and pizza as we dove into conversation.  While I entertained ordering wine with the food, I was still a little “overwhelmed” from celebrating my wife’s birthday and our 2nd anniversary the night before at Janos (www.janos.com) so I settled for iced tea. 

We all settled into our outdoor table, catching up on one another’s summer activities, when I noticed something that I had not seen in quite sometime: two very small glasses of red wine, each maybe 4 inches high at most and probably 2 inches in diameter.  I mean, these were SMALL….far more narrow than those found in a casual motel room!!  You certainly couldn’t swirl the wine, let alone place you nose through the opening for a sniff.  No, this glasses sent an subconscious message, “see me, gulp me,………..job done.”

The early evening was very festive with lots of laughter and energy and the food was enjoyable but somehow, I couldn’t keep myself from glancing at those odd glasses.  They just seemed a hypocrisy to the enjoyment of wine.  To me, it also sent the message that this restaurant had no intention of making wine an equal partner its cuisine, which was quite tasty.  I almost felt as if the wine was left over from a used jug or bottle.  Nonetheless, I was silent on my feelings for the entire evening until we got to the very end. 

I guess it was too many glances or just thinking too much.  Just as my friend was sipping from her second glass, I blurted out “ I can’t stand it when a restaurant pours wine into a tiny, motel bathroom glass.”  I was met with a barrage of counter responses that varied from “they do this all over Europe” to “you’re just a wine snob!”  Despite my protests about the inability to scent, swirl and taste the wine, it all fell on deaf ears.  No one seemed to care……….but me.  Imagine, I said, if a restaurant served a fragrant, stylish dish in a coffee cup where you couldn’t enjoy its presentation and the aromas were stifled?  They just laughed and shrugged their shoulders as if to say……..dream on.

However, their statement about my becoming a wine snob did resonate with me.  It made me wonder if they were on to something.  If I were not so consumed with wine, would I have felt the same?  For those who enjoy wine only occasionally, does it really matter to them whether the wine sits in “proper” stemware or in a motel glass?  Probably not.  We out for a very casual mid summer dinner and the size of the wine glass made not one  iota of difference in their experience. 

Perhaps, I’ve become just too stuffy, even in the most casual setting.  Could it be that I have extended my expectations in the fine dining setting to the most casual one?  Is it realistic to think that the service settings, including the wine stemware, should always be up to my standard?  Perhaps, the restaurant was cutting costs by utilizing these glasses or perhaps too many customers had broken stemmed glasses on the outdoor tables? 

Worse yet…………perhaps I am becoming a wine snob?  What do you think about this?  Does the glass make any difference to you??  Let us hear from you in the Community Forum.


Popularity: 2% [?]

6 Comments - Submit Your Comment to “Have I Become A Wine Snob??”

  1. El Jefe says:

    hi Jim – I’ve consumed wines from a variety of containers, including the bottle itself. I absolutely agree that the aromas and flavors are different between a nice stem vs. a water glass vs. right from the bottle.

    But I think the thing to remember is that in most situations the wine is not the star, it is a social seasoning. And while it does cause me a little cringe, knowing everything it took to get that wine into that bottle, to see it consumed in a less than perfect way…. what really matters is that you were having fun and food with your friends. If what I made helped you enjoy your food and friends a little more, who cares what kind of glass (or paper cup ;) you drank it from?

    Cheers! – j

  2. admin says:

    Apart from all the decor that is part of the wine and food experience, my aim, always, is to share with company……….that’s what wine and food are for…

  3. josh says:

    All of the admittedly scant research into wine glass sizes and shapes and how they affect wine aromas and tastes suggests that the glass doesn’t matter. Let me repeat that for those who have become addicted to Rieddle’s version of crack, the wine glass doesn’t matter. It’s all in our heads.

    That being said, I’m superstitious so I like to use nice glasses anyway. I also think nicer glasses (larger, elegant, appropriately shaped) add to the overall enjoyment of a particular experience. Thus, while technically bunk, I do like to use decent glasses because, well, I like them.

    While I don’t bat an eye or think snob of anyone who wants nice glasses for wine, I guess I do raise an eyebrow when people can’t get over it instantly. When the wine, wine glass or whatever is not to your liking order what is to your liking. Order a beer, an iced tea, a negroni and be happy with what you got.

    It’s not exactly snobbery but it is a bit overly specialized to think that every social food setting requires wine.

  4. Tim Hilcove says:

    Yes, you might have become a wine snob, but that’s not such a bad thing. I recently took a trip to Vancouver Canada where I used to live, and had dinner at one of my favorite downtown bistro’s. I was amazed at the wine list. Amazingly bad wine for way too much money. Who wants to enjoy a $15 entre with a bottle of Rosemont Shiraz which costs $40?! So I drank Stella Artois instead. If I can’t have decent wine at a reasonable price, I’m just going to drink beer instead :)

  5. [...] house a fine wine in the same glass as water, coke, etc.  I’ve written about this before in my Blog.  You don’t get to appreciate the wine’s color and its texture.  I make no apologies here for [...]

  6. [...] whined endlessly last year when a restaurant served red wine to me in a small table glass and I took issue with that behavior, as well.  But to do the word justice, I thought that I would research the definition of [...]

Leave a Reply


Dos Cabezas Wineworks
Advertise with Us
Wine & Food Pairing Guide
Wine Finder!
Lotus Garden
Callaghan Vineyards
Primo
  • Polls

    • How would you respond if asked to vacate your restaurant table after finishing dinner but no longer ordering food?

      View Results

      Loading ... Loading ...
  • Find us on Twitter and Facebook
    Local Events
    Wine News
    Recipes